Traditional Banks vs Alternative Lenders

⚡ Quick Answer:

Banks: 8-12% rates, 2-4 week approval, strict requirements, best for established businesses. Alternative Lenders: 15-28% rates, 24-72hr approval, flexible requirements, best for urgent funding or newer businesses.

Traditional Banks
Lower rates • Slower approval • Stricter criteria
Alternative Lenders
Higher rates • Fast approval • Flexible criteria
Compare Your Options Calculate Rates

People Also Ask

Are alternative lenders safe?

Yes, licensed alternative lenders are regulated by the Commerce Commission and must comply with responsible lending laws.

Can I refinance from alternative to bank?

Yes, many businesses use alternative lenders temporarily then refinance to banks once they meet criteria.

Do banks check alternative lending history?

Yes, banks review all existing debts including alternative loans when assessing applications.

Which is actually cheaper long-term?

Banks are always cheaper for interest, but factor in opportunity cost of waiting vs immediate funding.

Complete Side-by-Side Comparison

Factor Traditional Banks Alternative Lenders Winner
Interest Rates 8% - 12% 15% - 28% 🏆 Banks
Approval Speed 2-4 weeks 24-72 hours 🏆 Alternative
Loan Amounts $10K - $10M+ $5K - $500K 🏆 Banks
Min Time Trading 2+ years 6+ months 🏆 Alternative
Min Revenue Required $300K - $500K $75K - $100K 🏆 Alternative
Credit Score Required 650+ (Good) 500+ (Fair) 🏆 Alternative
Documentation Extensive Minimal 🏆 Alternative
Security Required Usually property Often unsecured 🏆 Alternative
Loan Terms 1-30 years 3-24 months 🏆 Banks
Customer Service Branch + Phone Online + Phone 🤝 Tie

Summary: Banks win on cost and terms, Alternative Lenders win on speed and accessibility.

What are Traditional Banks?

Quick Answer: Traditional banks are established financial institutions like ANZ, ASB, BNZ, and Westpac that offer business loans at competitive rates with strict requirements.

How do traditional banks work?

Traditional banks use conservative lending criteria, requiring extensive documentation, property security, and proven business performance. They manually review applications through credit committees, which takes 2-4 weeks but results in lower interest rates.

Why choose traditional banks?

✅ Advantages:

  • Lowest interest rates (8-12%)
  • Large loan amounts available
  • Long repayment terms (up to 30 years)
  • Established reputation and trust
  • Relationship banking benefits
  • Multiple products under one roof

❌ Disadvantages:

  • Slow approval (2-4 weeks)
  • Strict eligibility requirements
  • Extensive documentation needed
  • Usually require property security
  • Minimum 2 years trading history
  • High rejection rates (60%+)

Typical Bank Requirements:

  • • 2+ years in business
  • • $300K+ annual revenue
  • • Profitable or clear path to profit
  • • Good credit score (650+)
  • • Detailed financial statements
  • • Business plan and forecasts
  • • Property or asset security
  • • Personal guarantees from directors

What are Alternative Lenders?

Quick Answer: Alternative lenders are non-bank financial companies that use technology and flexible criteria to provide fast business funding at higher rates.

How do alternative lenders work?

Alternative lenders use automated credit assessment, analyzing bank data, cash flow, and business performance in real-time. They can approve loans in 24-72 hours without property security, making them accessible to businesses that don't qualify for bank loans.

Why choose alternative lenders?

✅ Advantages:

  • Fast approval (24-72 hours)
  • Minimal documentation required
  • Flexible eligibility criteria
  • No property security needed
  • 6 months trading sufficient
  • Bad credit considered
  • Simple online application
  • High approval rates (70%+)

❌ Disadvantages:

  • High interest rates (15-28%)
  • Shorter terms (3-24 months)
  • Smaller amounts ($500K max)
  • Daily/weekly repayments
  • Early repayment penalties
  • Less established reputation
  • Limited relationship benefits
  • Can create debt spiral

Types of Alternative Lenders:

  • • Online lenders: Prospa, Moula
  • • P2P platforms: Harmoney
  • • Invoice finance: Timelio, ScotPac
  • • Merchant cash: Square, PayPal
  • • Equipment finance: Bizcap
  • • Trade finance: Octet

How Much More Do Alternative Lenders Really Cost?

Let's compare the real cost difference on a $100,000 business loan:

Traditional Bank Loan

Loan Amount: $100,000
Interest Rate: 10% p.a.
Term: 3 years
Monthly Payment: $3,227
Total Interest Paid: $16,172
Total Repayment: $116,172

Alternative Lender Loan

Loan Amount: $100,000
Interest Rate: 22% p.a.
Term: 18 months
Weekly Payment: $1,510
Total Interest Paid: $17,910
Total Repayment: $117,910

Key Insight: While alternative lenders charge higher rates, shorter terms can sometimes result in similar total interest costs. However, the higher repayments can strain cash flow.

When Should You Choose Banks vs Alternative Lenders?

Choose Traditional Banks When:

  • ✓
    You can wait 2-4 weeks

    No urgent cash flow needs

  • ✓
    You've been trading 2+ years

    With profitable track record

  • ✓
    You have property security

    Commercial or residential

  • ✓
    You need $250K+ funding

    For major investments

  • ✓
    You want lowest rates

    Cost is primary concern

  • ✓
    You have good credit

    650+ credit score

Choose Alternative Lenders When:

  • ✓
    You need money within 72 hours

    Urgent opportunity or crisis

  • ✓
    You're a newer business

    6 months to 2 years old

  • ✓
    You lack property security

    Renting or no assets

  • ✓
    You have seasonal revenue

    Banks don't understand

  • ✓
    Banks rejected you

    Don't meet strict criteria

  • ✓
    You have bad credit

    Below 650 score

The Smart Hybrid Strategy

Many successful businesses use BOTH traditional banks and alternative lenders strategically:

📈 The Growth Ladder Strategy

  1. 1
    Start with alternative lender

    Get quick funding when banks won't approve you (6-12 months old)

  2. 2
    Build business track record

    Use the funding to grow revenue and improve financials

  3. 3
    Refinance to bank loan

    After 18-24 months, qualify for cheaper bank rates

  4. 4
    Keep alternative lender as backup

    Use for urgent opportunities banks are too slow for

Use Banks For:

  • • Long-term capital investments
  • • Property purchases
  • • Equipment over $100K
  • • Refinancing expensive debt

Use Alternative For:

  • • Urgent opportunities
  • • Short-term cash flow
  • • Seasonal inventory
  • • Emergency funding

Common Myths Debunked

❌ Myth: Alternative lenders are loan sharks

Reality: Licensed alternative lenders are regulated by the Commerce Commission and must follow responsible lending laws. They're legitimate businesses, just with different risk models than banks.

❌ Myth: Banks always offer the best deal

Reality: If waiting 4 weeks for bank approval costs you a $50K contract, paying higher rates for quick funding can be more profitable overall.

❌ Myth: Using alternative lenders hurts your credit

Reality: Responsible borrowing and repayment improves your credit regardless of lender type. It's defaulting that hurts credit, not the lender choice.

❌ Myth: You can't negotiate with alternative lenders

Reality: Many alternative lenders will negotiate rates, especially for larger loans or if you have multiple offers.

Our Expert Recommendation

There's no universal "better" option - it depends entirely on your business situation:

The 80/20 Rule for Business Lending

✅ 80% of established businesses should try banks first

If you meet the criteria and can wait, the savings are substantial. A 10% rate difference on $200K saves you $20,000 per year.

✅ 20% genuinely need alternative lenders

For urgent funding, newer businesses, or those without traditional security. The higher cost is worth the accessibility and speed.

💡 The Smart Move

Apply to banks first if you can wait. If rejected or need funds urgently, use alternative lenders. Consider it a stepping stone, not a permanent solution.

Compare Both Bank and Alternative Lending Options

Get matched with the right lender for YOUR situation - not a one-size-fits-all approach

No obligation. Our specialists will contact you within 24 hours with personalized loan options.